Jackson v. Louisiana: the constitutional right to a unanimous jury

This week, Constitutional Accountability Center, along with our co-counsel, Ben Cohen of The Promise of Justice Initiative, filed a petition for a writ of certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court on behalf of Ortiz T. Jackson, urging the Court to hear his case, Jackson v. Louisiana. This is the first time CAC has represented an individual seeking review. 

Jackson v. Louisiana raises a question central to the Sixth Amendment’s guarantee of the right to a trial by jury: whether an individual may be convicted of a crime even if the jury in his case cannot reach a unanimous verdict.  Both Louisiana and Oregon, alone among the 50 states, permit non-unanimous jury verdicts in criminal cases, and each year, criminal defendants in those states are convicted by non-unanimous juries, even in felony cases that carry a potential sentence of life in prison.  In November 2008, the state of Louisiana charged Mr. Jackson with murder.  Mr. Jackson, who has denied any involvement in the murder, filed a motion to require a unanimous jury verdict, which was denied by the trial court.  Mr. Jackson was subsequently found guilty of second-degree murder by a jury vote of 10-2, and sentenced to life in prison at hard labor without the benefit of parole, probation, or suspension of sentence.  The appeals court affirmed Mr. Jackson’s conviction, and the state supreme court denied Mr. Jackson’s request for review.

State courts in both Louisiana and Oregon have refused to consider the constitutionality of their respective state’s non-unanimous jury rule based primarily on the Supreme Court’s badly fractured 4-1-4 decision in the 1972 case Apodaca v. Oregon, which held that state criminal juries may convict a defendant without unanimous jury consent.  Our cert. petition in Jackson demonstrates that Apodaca is not only inconsistent with the history and purposes of the Sixth Amendment, but also with the Court’s more recent case law, and urges the Court to review Jackson in order to put an end to the unconstitutional practices in Louisiana and Oregon. 

We argue, among other things, that convicting criminal defendants without the unanimous consent of a jury denies these individuals a right that the Framers viewed as fundamental.  As our petition demonstrates, the Framers understood the unanimity of a jury to be as much a part of the jury right as the right to a jury of one’s neighbors and peers.  To the Framers, the requirement of jury unanimity was critical to ensuring the full and fair jury deliberations that the Sixth Amendment requires.  Indeed, more recent empirical research supports the Framers’ view that jury unanimity is essential to the jury as a bulwark of liberty.  Specifically, evidence has shown that when unanimity is required, jurors evaluate evidence more thoroughly, spend more time deliberating, and are more likely to consider all viewpoints.

The Court will likely decide later this year whether to hear Jackson.

More from

Rule of Law
November 16, 2026

The Right Way to do Congressional Oversight

Washington Monthly
CAC’s Elizabeth Wydra and Praveen Fernandes wrote in Washington Monthly about the next steps Congress...
By: Elizabeth B. Wydra, Praveen Fernandes
Civil and Human Rights
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

American Council of Learned Societies v. McDonald

In American Council of Learned Societies v. McDonald, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit is considering whether DOGE’s targeted terminations of federal humanities grants that studied race, gender, and other protected traits...
Rule of Law
November 13, 2026

November 2026 Newsletter: Our Takeaways from This Year’s Midterm Elections

Earlier this month, voters made their voices heard, and they plainly had a lot to...
Rule of Law
November 11, 2026

The Democrats Need to Think Bigger on Supreme Court Reform

Slate
CAC’s Elizabeth Wydra and David H. Gans wrote in Slate about Reconstruction’s lessons for Congress...
By: Elizabeth B. Wydra, David H. Gans
Immigration and Citizenship
November 10, 2026

CAC Release: Supreme Court Set to Clarify Public-Rights Doctrine as it Applies to Employers who Benefit from Immigrant Labor

WASHINGTON, DC – Following oral argument at the Supreme Court this morning in Department of...
By: Joshua Blecher-Cohen, Smita Ghosh
Civil and Human Rights
November 9, 2026

CAC Release: Supreme Court Precedent and Constitutional History Both Support Access to Court When Prison Staff Violate the Eighth Amendment

WASHINGTON, DC – Following oral argument at the Supreme Court this morning in Nielsen v....
By: Joshua Blecher-Cohen, David H. Gans