Rule of Law

Former Labor Board Watchdog Sues Trump Over ‘Blatant Violation’ Firing

Gwynne Wilcox, who served as chairman of the NLRB until Monday, January 27, has described her own removal as “unprecedented and illegal”

The former head of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), a US labor watchdog agency, is suing President Donald Trump over her termination as an NLRB board member after the 47th President suddenly removed her from her position last week.

Gwynne Wilcox, who served as chairman of the NLRB until Monday, January 27, has described her own removal as “unprecedented and illegal”. She has filed a lawsuit against Trump and the man he hired to replace her, Marvin Kaplan, stating that she was dismissed for a “blatantly political purpose that flies in the face of the NLRB’s independent status,” according to the Guardian.

Wilcox, who was appointed to her position last December by President Joe Biden, was set to finish out her term in 2028. If her termination is executed, she will become the first board member to be removed since 1935.

She has pointed out that examples of “neglect of duty or malfeasance in office” are required to dismiss an NLRB member, something Trump did not provide before firing her.

Her removal from the board means that the NLRB consists only of two remaining members, hence they cannot meet the three-member quorum required for them to issue decisions. Hence, the watchdog agency is unable to make calls on open investigations into workplace violations, union petitions or unfair labor practices.

Wilcox is seeking an injunction that would reinstate her to her position as chairman of the board so that the watchdog may continue to operate as a congressionally mandated independent agency. She has stated that she intends to pursue “all legal avenues” to appeal her termination.

“President Trump’s firing of an NLRB Member without good cause flies in the face of that precedent and practice and is blatantly unconstitutional,” said Brian Frazelle, deputy chief counsel for the Constitutional Accountability Center.

“By leaving only two board members in their posts, the President has effectively shut down the National Labor Relations Board’s operations, leaving the workers it defends on their own in the face of union-busting and retaliation,” said Liz Shuler, President of the American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO).

“[These] moves will make it easier for bosses to violate the law and trample on workers’ legal rights on the job and fundamental freedom to organize,” Shuler continued. “Member Wilcox has already indicated she will challenge her firing, and we fully expect she will succeed in the courts and be restored to her position so she can continue to be a critical pro-worker voice on the NLRB.”

More from Rule of Law

Rule of Law
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia

Cristosal Human Rights v. Marocco

In Cristosal Human Rights v. Marocco, the United States District Court for the District of Columbia is considering whether the Trump administration’s unilateral decision to defund and dismantle the Inter-American Foundation violates federal law and...
Rule of Law
March 18, 2025

Feds, NLRB’s Wilcox urge quick ruling on reinstatement

HR Dive
The defendants said a district court’s ruling “works a grave harm to the separation of...
Rule of Law
March 18, 2025

RELEASE: At Oral Argument, D.C. Circuit Judges Contend with Dangerous and Unprecedented Claims for Unlimited Executive Power over Longstanding Independent Agencies

WASHINGTON, DC – Following oral argument at the D.C. Circuit court today in Wilcox v....
Rule of Law
U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit

New York v. Trump

In New York v. Trump, the First Circuit is considering whether the Trump administration’s unilateral and categorical decision to freeze all federal funding to programs that do not align with its policy priorities violates federal...
Rule of Law
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Pacito v. Trump

In Pacito v. Trump, the Ninth Circuit is considering whether the Trump administration’s unilateral decision to dismantle the United States Refugee Assistance Program (USRAP), including by suspending all USRAP funding, violates federal law and the...
Rule of Law
March 13, 2025

March 2025 Newsletter: Ongoing Challenges and New Victories